By Barkha Arora
Sometimes, the weight of expectations can crush even the most well-intentioned efforts—and that’s precisely what happens with Sitaare Zameen Par. Aamir Khan’s much-anticipated return to the big screen comes with a borrowed soul and a familiar name, but not nearly enough originality to make it shine.
This film, directed by R.S. Prasanna, is positioned as an emotional, feel-good sports drama. But it stumbles under the weight of expectations, trying to live up to two colossal legacies: one being the original Spanish film Campeones (and its English adaptation Champions), and the other, more dangerously, Aamir’s own iconic Taare Zameen Par. Borrowing a nearly identical name while riding on nostalgia proves to be a risky move—one that backfires, given how the audience was primed to expect something equally soulful and fresh. Instead, what unfolds is a scene-by-scene adaptation with very little creative voice of its own.
A Familiar Story Told Too Safely
The film revolves around Gulshan (Aamir Khan), a short-tempered, once-promising basketball coach who is sentenced to community service after a court-mandated punishment. His assignment: coaching a team of young athletes with intellectual disabilities. While the core message about inclusion and empathy remains powerful, the treatment is disappointingly derivative.
From the courtroom drama to the training montages and emotional breakthroughs, every beat feels recycled from the original. Even Aamir’s performance, though technically sound, feels like déjà vu. His body language, tone, and expressions echo previous roles—especially his eccentric act in PK and the emotionally driven educator from Taare Zameen Par. At one point, I recalled his audition for Laapataa Ladies, where similar traits showed up—almost as if his characters are beginning to blend into each other rather than stand apart.
Star Cast and Technical Team
The film features Aamir Khan in the lead as Gulshan, supported by Genelia Deshmukh in a poised role. The ensemble includes ten debutant actors portraying the basketball team with heartfelt sincerity. Dolly Ahluwalia and Brijendra Kala round out the supporting cast. The story is written by Divy Nidhi Sharma, with cinematography by G. Srinivas Reddy and editing by Charu Shree Roy. Music by Shankar–Ehsaan–Loy (songs) and Ram Sampath (background score) adds emotional texture, though even that feels somewhat predictable.
Good Intentions, Safe Execution
It’s important to acknowledge the film’s heart is in the right place. It promotes inclusion, sensitivity, and compassion in a world increasingly distracted by superficial achievements. Yet, for a filmmaker and actor known for pushing boundaries, this film plays it far too safe.
Aamir Khan, often hailed as Bollywood’s “perfectionist,” seems here to be chasing the shadows of past success instead of crafting new ones. His silence on relevant issues in the public domain, combined with recent controversies like his association with Turkish officials and the Laal Singh Chaddha backlash, has already led to image fatigue. People now expect not just precision from him, but also relevance, reinvention, and resonance.
And that’s where Sitaare Zameen Par falls short. It’s not a bad film—it’s a missed opportunity. Aamir could have taken the essence of Campeones and layered it with Indian socio-cultural nuances, added new dialogues, scenes, or even shifted the setting for a deeper contextual impact. Instead, what we get is a frame-by-frame copy, polished but predictable.
Final Verdict: A Dimmed Shine
In my view, Sitaare Zameen Par is a film that plays by the rules when it should have redefined them. While the subject is noble and the performances sincere, the lack of originality in storytelling and visual treatment limits its impact. When you brand a film with a title that recalls one of your best works, you invite comparisons. And sadly, this one doesn’t hold up.
It’s a decent watch, especially for families or viewers unfamiliar with the original Spanish film. But for those who expected Aamir Khan’s roaring comeback—this feels more like a gentle echo.
Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3.5/5)
High on emotion, low on innovation.
Follow us on Instagram : HIGH ON PERSONA MAGAZINE (@highonpersonamagazine) • Instagram photos and videos
https://www.highonpersona.com/bhool-chuk-maaf-review-rajkummar-rao-shines-in-this-time-loop-rom-com/